The Craving Mind — Why "More" Rarely Feels Like Enough
Towards the end of Sapiens, after hundreds of pages charting empires, revolutions and scientific breakthroughs, Yuval Noah Harari pauses to ask a deceptively simple question.
With all our progress, are we actually any happier?
It is a question that stopped me in my tracks. Because it is not only a question about humanity. It is a question about each of us, and it tends to arrive with particular force in midlife.
The mind that always wants something
In exploring happiness, Harari turns to an insight at the heart of Buddhist philosophy: that much of our suffering arises not from our circumstances, but from craving.
The mind, left to its own devices, is restless. When we experience something pleasant, we want it to last and to intensify. When we experience something unpleasant, we want it gone. And even when things are perfectly fine, we often crave something more: more certainty, more recognition, more calm, more excitement.
The result is a mind that is rarely at rest in the present moment. It is always leaning forward, reaching for the next feeling, the next achievement, the next reassurance.
Harari's point, drawing on this tradition, is striking. Real contentment may come less from chasing pleasant feelings and more from understanding their passing nature, and from loosening our grip on the constant pursuit of them.
As a coach, I find this idea both humbling and freeing. Because I see the craving mind at work in so many of the conversations I have with women at this stage of life.
Moving the goalposts
Psychologists have studied a related pattern known as hedonic adaptation, sometimes called the hedonic treadmill. We adapt remarkably quickly to good fortune. The promotion, the new home, the longed-for holiday: each brings a lift, and then, often sooner than we expect, it simply becomes the new normal.
Harari makes a similar observation: our sense of happiness depends heavily on our expectations. When our circumstances improve, our expectations tend to rise to meet them. And so the satisfaction we imagined slips just out of reach once again.
Many of us will recognise the inner refrain.
I'll relax when the children are settled.
I'll feel secure when the mortgage is paid off.
I'll be happy when I've lost the weight, got the qualification, finished the project, sorted the house.
And then the moment arrives. We feel a brief glow of relief. And almost immediately, the mind finds a new when.
This is not a personal failing. It is, in a sense, how the human mind was built: to keep striving, to keep scanning for what is missing. That served our ancestors well. It does not always serve us well in midlife, on a quiet Sunday afternoon.
The luxury trap in our own lives
Earlier in Sapiens, describing the Agricultural Revolution, Harari introduces another idea I find deeply relevant to midlife: the luxury trap.
His argument is that luxuries have a way of becoming necessities. Each step towards an easier life creates new obligations, and once we have grown used to a certain standard, it becomes very hard to go back. What began as a choice quietly turns into a requirement.
I see versions of this in many women's lives. The larger house that now needs more upkeep. The career level that demands ever more of our evenings. The lifestyle that requires a certain income, which requires a certain job, which requires a certain version of ourselves.
None of these were mistakes. Many were wonderful choices at the time. But it is worth noticing when the things we acquired to make life better have begun to quietly run our lives instead.
What craving looks like in midlife
Craving does not only attach itself to possessions or achievements. In midlife, I notice it often takes subtler forms:
Craving the past: the body we had at thirty, the energy we had at forty, the years when the children still needed us every day.
Craving control: the wish to guarantee that our parents stay well, our children stay safe and nothing unexpected ever happens again.
Craving approval: the need to be seen as the good daughter, the capable colleague, the woman who still has it all together.
Craving reinvention: the pressure, often fuelled by social media, to have a dramatic, photogenic second act.
Craving certainty: wanting to know exactly how the next chapter will turn out before we dare to begin it.
Each of these is deeply human. None of them makes you shallow or ungrateful. But each carries the same hidden cost: it pulls our attention away from the life we are actually living, here, today.
Wanting is not the problem
I want to be clear about something, because this idea is easily misunderstood.
This is not an argument against ambition, desire or hope. A life without wanting anything would be a strange and colourless one. Many of the most meaningful changes I have witnessed in my clients began with a woman finally allowing herself to want something.
The difference lies between desire and craving.
Desire can be spacious. It says: I would love this, and I will work towards it, but my sense of worth does not depend on getting it.
Craving is tighter and more anxious. It says: I cannot be at peace until I have this. And because the mind can always find a new this, peace keeps getting postponed.
In coaching, a great deal of the work is helping women notice which one is driving them. A goal pursued from desire tends to feel energising. A goal pursued from craving tends to feel like a debt that can never quite be paid off.
Practising enough
So what might we do with this insight? Not as a rigid programme, but as gentle practice.
Notice the "when". Each time you catch yourself thinking I'll be happy when…, pause and ask: Is there anything here, today, that is already enough?
Name the craving. Simply labelling it — this is craving approval, this is craving control — can loosen its grip. Mindfulness research consistently suggests that observing a feeling with curiosity changes our relationship with it.
Audit your luxury traps. Look at one area of life that feels heavy. Which of its demands are truly necessary, and which are simply habits we grew into?
Savour on purpose. Hedonic adaptation dulls what we stop noticing. Deliberately slowing down to appreciate the ordinary — a conversation, a walk by the sea, a quiet coffee — is one of the simplest antidotes.
Hold goals more lightly. Keep your dreams, but ask whether you can pursue them without making your peace conditional on them.
A different kind of bloom
Perhaps one of the quiet gifts of midlife is that we have lived long enough to see the pattern. We have reached enough summits to know that the view, wonderful as it is, never quite stops the mind from looking for the next peak.
That recognition can feel disappointing at first. But it can also be profoundly liberating.
Because if more was never going to be enough, then perhaps enough was always available to us in a different way. Not as a destination we finally arrive at, but as a way of meeting the life already in front of us.
A second bloom does not have to mean acquiring more, achieving more or becoming more. Sometimes it means wanting a little less, and noticing a great deal more.

Your reflection for this week
Where in your life are you waiting for a "when" before you allow yourself to feel content?
Which form of craving do you recognise most in yourself right now?
Is there a luxury in your life that has quietly become a trap?
What is already enough, today, that you may have stopped noticing?
As always, I would love to hear your reflections. Share them in the comments or bring them to The Second Bloom Life community.
The Second Bloom Life
The mind will always find something more to want. A second bloom begins when we learn to notice what is already here.



Comments