What Bologna Knows About Being Unfinished
Bologna has a way of showing you the parts it never got round to finishing. At fifty-three, I found that unexpectedly comforting.
I arrived in the centro storico expecting the usual pilgrimage of a city break: the famous sights, ticked off in order, admired from the correct angle. Bologna had other ideas.
The porticoes do something to your pace. Some sixty kilometres of covered arcades wind through the city, so you are never quite out in the open and never quite indoors. You walk in a kind of in-between. Somewhere along Strada Maggiore, it struck me that this is exactly where midlife lives. Not the beginning, not the end, but the long, sheltered middle stretch where you can finally hear your own footsteps.
That street delivers you to the foot of the Due Torri, and it was there that I began to notice something. Bologna's most famous landmarks are not monuments to completion. They are monuments to compromise, adjustment and work left half-done.
Everyone photographs the two towers as a pair, but they are not equals. The Asinelli rises 97 metres, straight and proud. Beside it stands the Garisenda, barely half that height and leaning at an angle that makes you instinctively tilt your head to match it.
In the Middle Ages the city bristled with towers; historians reckon there were dozens, perhaps as many as a hundred. Rival families built them as statements: look how high we can go. Only a handful survive today, the rest pulled down, collapsed or quietly absorbed into other buildings.
Here is the part nobody puts on the postcard. The Garisenda was once around sixty metres tall. When it began to lean dangerously in the fourteenth century, the city neither pulled it down nor pretended all was well. It took the top off, bringing the tower down to roughly forty-eight metres. It was made smaller so that it could keep standing.
I stood at the barrier and thought about all the ways I have been asked, at this age, to keep building upwards. More qualifications. More output. More proof. And I thought about the quiet wisdom of a structure that has stood for nearly seven centuries since that cut, precisely because someone agreed to let it be less tall.
There is a word we rarely use kindly about women in midlife: diminished. The Garisenda offers another reading. Sometimes you shed height to keep your footing. Sometimes the cut is the very thing that saves you.
Today both towers are fenced off while the Garisenda is held steady by steel frames and cables, some of it the very equipment once used to stabilise the Leaning Tower of Pisa. The restoration is expected to run for years. It is, quite literally, being propped up, and with borrowed support at that. Still, people stop, crane their necks and call it beautiful. Needing help has not made it any less of a landmark. I found myself wishing I extended the same courtesy to myself.
I followed Via Rizzoli west, and within a few minutes Piazza Maggiore opened up in front of me, with San Petronio filling one side of it. My eye went straight to the façade, then did a double-take. The lower part is dressed in pale, carved marble. Above it, the marble simply stops, and the rest is rough, bare brick, as if the workmen downed tools one afternoon and never came back.
In a sense, they never did. The building began in 1390. In the sixteenth century a grander plan was drawn up, one that would have outsized St Peter's in Rome; legend has it that the Pope made sure this never happened, placing the university's new Archiginnasio right where one arm of the basilica should have stood. Money ran short and politics intervened. Some of the great architects of the age, Palladio and Vignola among them, submitted designs for the façade. None was ever built. Six centuries on, the brick is still showing.
What moved me is that Bologna never waited. In 1530, in a church that was still largely a building site, a pope crowned Charles V emperor here. Generations of Bolognesi have worshipped, married and sheltered inside, and argued on its steps. The unfinished basilica became one of the best-loved spaces in the city, not in spite of its incompleteness but alongside it.
So many women I work with are waiting for their own marble to be finished. When I've lost the weight. When the children have settled. When I've healed, sorted my career, worked out who I am now. Then, they say, life will properly begin. San Petronio would like a word: you do not need a finished façade to open your doors.
Step inside and most visitors look up. I would ask you to look down. Running diagonally across the floor of the nave is a long brass line set into the stone: a meridian, laid out in 1655 by the astronomer Giovanni Domenico Cassini. Some twenty-seven metres up in the vault there is a tiny hole. At solar noon, an image of the sun falls through it and lands somewhere along the line, which stretches for more than sixty-seven metres and is said to be the longest of its kind in the world. Where the light lands tells you the true position of the sun, and with it the season and the date.
It does not tell you what time you would like it to be. It tells you what time it is.
I think of midlife as the moment the light comes through that small hole in the roof. For years we run on borrowed clocks: other people's expectations, the timetable we were handed at twenty-five. Then, somewhere in our forties or fifties, a clearer light falls on the floor and shows us where we actually are. Not where we thought we would be, nor where we are told we should be. Just here. It can be uncomfortable to read. But Cassini built his line so that people could stop guessing, and there is real relief in knowing the true hour, even when it is later than you hoped.
I left as the light was going and walked back beneath the porticoes, past the fenced-off towers, the half-dressed basilica behind me. Bologna, it occurred to me, does not have its life sorted. It has a tower on cables, a basilica in its work clothes and a floor that tells the truth about time. It is also one of the warmest, most liveable and quietly confident places I know.
Perhaps that is the unexpected gift of midlife. Not the grand finish we were promised, but permission to stop waiting for one. To be a little shorter where we needed to be. To open the doors before the marble is done. To read the real light and walk on, sheltered, at our own pace.
I am unfinished. So, it turns out, is everything worth visiting.
Where in your life are you still waiting for the façade to be finished? I'd love to hear. Come and join the conversation in The Second Bloom Life on Facebook, or find me on Instagram at @thesecondbloomlife.




Comments